IPv6 News

Lost in all the discussion around the recent ITU meeting (TIES account required of course) is any discussion of the current policy regarding the formation of new RIRs.

You may recall that one of the reports that the ITU commissioned on this subject suggests that it would be possible, even desirable for the ITU to be allocated a /12 of IPv6 from the IANA to be further allocated to Country Internet Registries.

Here is why that idea can’t possibly happen:

1) The region of coverage should meet the scale to be defined by ICANN, given the need to avoid global address fragmentation

The proposed RIR must operate internationally in a large geographical region of approximately continental size.

Each region should be served by a single RIR, established under one management and in one location. The establishment of multiple RIRs in one region is likely to lead to:

• fragmentation of address space allocated to the region;

• difficulty for co-ordination and co-operation between the RIRs;

• confusion for the community within the region.

This document, which was accepted in 2001 by the ICANN Board of Directors as “a statement of essential requirements for the recognition of new Regional Internet Registries (RIRs), in supplementation to section 9 of the ASO-Memorandum of Understanding, and acknowledged it as a framework for consideration of applications for recognition of new RIRs.” sets out a number of principles that clearly delineate how to start a new RIR. The fact that the ITU commissioned report doesn’t even meet the first principle seems to indicate that the “researchers” didn’t do their “research”.

There are other “Principles” enshrined in this policy as well, which could arguably exclude the ITU from taking on this role:

2) The new RIR must demonstrate that it has the broad support of the LIRs (ISP community) in the proposed region

3) Bottom-up self-governance structure for setting local policies

4) Neutrality and impartiality in relation to all interested parties, and particularly the LIRs

5) Technical expertise

6) Adherence to global policies regarding address space conservation, aggregation and registration

One doesn’t need to argue them at all however, as the first principle clearly excludes the duplication of the RIR functions according to Dr. Ramadass plan. Obviously, if the ITU were to set up a global registry, it would violate the “approximately continental size” requirement, and if there were a global “RIR” run by the ITU it would run afoul of the requirement that “Each region should be served by a single RIR, established under one management and in one location.”

So it’s a non-starter, its quite clear, it just can’t happen according to the current policy. However, since one of the the outcomes of the ITU meeting held on March 15th and 16th is two email “correspondence groups”, one to study outreach and capacity building about IPv6, and the second to study the concerns that developing nations have about IPv6 distribution and how the existing RIR system can address them, it seems we are still going to be discussing this issue going forward.

In the East African country where I live, I have been asked to sit on a 4 person ad hoc committee to further discuss what the “national position” should be on this topic. In my opinion the “national position” should be “let’s just get on with IPv6 deployment and quit worrying about who does the allocating, as that is not going to change!”

Written by McTim, IP Resource Consultant

[Read more →]

Georgia Tech’s computer-science researchers have come up with an innovative wireless system called LifeNet, which, because it combines the host client and router function in the LifeNet-enabled mobile device, can allow for setup of a mobile ad-hoc network that could help in emergency response or in places with little network infrastructure.
Complete info at NetworkWorld, ComputerWorld and CIO.

[Read more →]

Network engineers from Yahoo are pitching what they admit is a “really ugly hack” to the Internet’s Domain Name System, but they say it is necessary for the popular Web content provider to support IPv6, the long-anticipated upgrade to the Internet’s main communications protocol.
Complete info at NetworkWorld, ComputerWorld and CIO.

[Read more →]

Controversial proposal would enable content providers to serve up content to those IP addresses on the list via IPv6 rather than through IPv4.
Complete info at InfoWorld, ComputerWorld and NetworkWorld.

[Read more →]

Research and Markets has announced the addition of the “Indonesia – Internet and Broadband Services” report to their offering.
Complete info at TMCnet.

[Read more →]

Korenix announces Compact Programmable Embedded VPN Routing Computer JetBox 5430-w with -40~80oC Wide Operating Temp. for High-Performance & Secure VPN Network Constructions in Severe Front-End Controller Applications!.
Complete info at newswireToday!.

[Read more →]

The possibility of sharing a list of customers able to access websites via IPv6 is in early stage discussion by leading internet companies including Google, Yahoo, Netflix and Microsoft. “The DNS Whitelist for IPv6 would be a list of IP addresses that have functioning IPv6 connectivity,” Carolyn Duffy Marsan of Network World reports. “The shared DNS Whitelist for IPv6 is a controversial proposal, with content providers saying it is the only viable option for offering IPv6 services today, and ISPs worrying that maintaining the whitelist will be an administrative burden in the future.”

Read full story: Network World

[Read more →]

This week, the IETF is holding its 77th meeting in Anaheim, California. Last year around this time, the IETF met in San Francisco, and the Internet Society took advantage of this large gathering of Internet engineers to promote IPv6 and tell us that that it’s high time to trade in the dusty 1980s Internet Protocol [...]

[Read more →]

This week, the IETF is holding its 77th meeting in Anaheim, California. Last year around this time, the IETF met in San Francisco, and the Internet Society took advantage of this large gathering of Internet engineers to promote IPv6 and tell us that that it’s high time to trade in the dusty 1980s Internet Protocol for the shiny 1995 version. Tuesday, the news was that people are actually starting to heed the advice.
Complete article at ars technica.

[Read more →]

Defying the global economic downturn by adding another 58 million lines of broadband technology in 2009, there are now more than 466.95 million broadband customers in the world according to statistics released today by the Broadband Forum.
Complete info at BI-ME.

[Read more →]